New-age cos could flip to phantom shares, warrants to reward founders

The market regulator’s expansive definition of promoters for firms going public could put them in a bind over easy methods to reward founders. Since promoters are ineligible to be granted worker inventory choice plans (ESOPs), the new-age corporations could flip to alternate options corresponding to phantom inventory items, warrants and sweat fairness to compensate founders.

The market regulator has been insisting that founders of IPO-bound firms holding 10 per cent or extra classify themselves as promoters. Even founders collectively holding 10 per cent are to be thought of promoters if they’re key managerial personnel (KMP) or a director within the firm.

Additionally learn: SEBI bans former TV anchor, analyst for 5 years

Payout of phantom inventory items — the place the items solely observe the upside of share worth and the profit is paid out in money — could achieve traction. These buildings adhere to the industrial necessities when it comes to making certain that the profit will accrue to the unitholders provided that there’s a progress in share worth.

‘No particular phrases’

“As that is unregulated, there are not any particular phrases beneath legislation that must complied with, like acquiring shareholders’ approval, minimal one-year cliff/vesting interval and cost of train value, and it turns into purely contractual in nature. This may give the businesses and founders much more flexibility in structuring how and when the advantages will accrue,” stated Bharath Reddy, Associate, Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas.

By way of its casual steering issued to MindTree and Saregama, SEBI has clarified that pure cash-based profit schemes which don’t deal in securities usually are not ruled by its share-based worker profit laws. “Even earlier than an IPO, the Firms Act, 2013, doesn’t allow the granting of inventory choices to a founder recognized as a promoter, apart from promoters of start-ups recognised by DPIIT. Because of this, unlisted firms have been incentivising such founders by granting phantom inventory choices,” stated Shabnam Shaikh, Associate, Khaitan & Co.

Additionally learn: SEBI to tweak choice standards for F&O shares

In situations the place an organization is cash-strapped or traders need founders to have extra at stake, new buildings are being explored. Founders are being granted convertible devices corresponding to optionally convertible desire shares or warrants. “These devices intently resemble worker inventory choices. If the vesting circumstances usually are not met, the warrants are forfeited or cancelled and the OCRPS are redeemed on the acquisition value,” stated Shaikh.

The conversion of warrants into shares, nonetheless, could create tax points, and if the share value is already excessive, the issuance of convertible shares may require the worker to incur vital upfront prices, added Shaikh.

Sweat fairness

An alternative choice is sweat fairness, which will be issued each pre- or post-IPO. Sweat fairness shares are fairness shares issued to the administrators or workers at a reduction or for a consideration apart from money for his or her know-how or experience delivered to the corporate.

Pre-IPO issuance, nonetheless, will add to the founders’ shareholding which can additional contribute to them being categorised as a promoter, stated Kriti Kaushik, Associate, Shardul Amarchand Mangaldas & Co.

Final 12 months, proxy advisory agency IiAS had petitioned SEBI to relook at whether or not Paytm founder Vijay Shekhar Sharma was eligible to obtain inventory choices. Sharma’s direct fairness holding on the time of the IPO had decreased to 9.1 per cent from 14.7 per cent earlier.